Feature:
More and more, "real" engineers are discovering the beauty of a pre-post setup when using one board for FOH and moniters. If you have to eq a channel to sound good out front, chances are the mons need it too.
My only complaint with the features - no inserts on the sub groups, but there's ways around that.
As far as recording goes, I'veonly used the Firewire out so I can't comment on the direct outs. The shows that I have recorded are beautiful. What was at the input is what's on disc. Most engineers don't use much if any eq while recording. They'll either process in the box or with outboard gear later. Once you record with eq, you're stuck.
Also you have to remember, this is a live board that can be used for recording not the other way around. If you want to use a Behringer board because it's cheaper, go ahead. You get what you pay for.
Quality:
Built tough - like every other Mackie I own or have owned. We've been using it for just under a year now with no problems and I don't expect any. Never had a problem with a Mackie except for what's noted below.
Value:
It's a fair price to pay for the sound quality and ease of use. Yes it would be nice if the Firewire card came with it but that's unrealistic. Plus, why should someone that doesn't need the card have to pay for it? Again, remember it's a live board with the ability to record.
As for the software with the card, I agree that it should come with all the extra plug-ins that are included with the stand alone software package. If I really needed the plug-ins, I would have to buy another copy of Traktion but I not going to put a negative for this on the mixer because this is a review of the mixer, not the card.
Desirability:
I own it and will probably buy another one later this year. Why probably? Because I'm waiting to take delivery ov my shiny new Onyx 24-4. Does that tell you enough of how much I like the sound and features of the mixer?
Sound:
The Onyx series is by far the best sounding board in it's class. The top end is pristine and clear, the mids warm and punchy, while the bottom is thick and smooth. Or it's flat - your choice. If you don't know the correct way to use an eq then it doesn't matter what mixer you have. Every other mixer - including Mackie's VLZ series sounds muffled and lifeless in comparison, even with the eq's flat. It's not "bright", it's CLEAR.
Ease of Use:
Everything is where it's supposed to be and easy to find. It's a little cramped by the faders if you want to change sub group assignments. Also the lack of inserts on the subs makes life a little more challenging but not impossible.
Support:
Any questions I've emailed tech support in the past have been quickly and politely answered. I haven't called.
My original CR1604 (remember those?) died half way through the first gig it went out on. Mackie had it fixed and shipped back UPS Red label in four days with an explanation of the problem and an apology!
Overall:
If it breaks, I will get it fixed. If it's stolen, I will buy another one.
9 of 12 people (75%) found this review helpful. Did you?
Thanks for your opinion!