Feature:
With the latest firmware upgrade, this recorder can do a lot. It's nice to have 8 virtual takes per track, really flexible routing (via ADAT optical or analog inputs/outputs), varispeed recording/playback, and more. The only thing I wish it had is an option to render tracks. Other than that, it's great. It records in .bwf format, so if you're reasonably computer savvy, you can build a dock for your computer and the SDR's external hard drive caddy, and then edit or mixdown on your computer. You can also hook up a remote and a footswitch, but those are sold separately. Also, for analog ins/outs, it does use db25 connections, which definitely add up in cost, since you need 6 snakes to fully hook everything up.
Quality:
So far, so good. I've heard of problems with some of the older machines, but haven't experienced any of them as of yet. The recorder itself is pretty sturdy. I wouldn't want it dropped or banged up too much, but I also wouldn't feel too bad about taking it on the road as long as I had appropriate protection for it.
Value:
There isn't a better product out there at this price point. Sure, the cables will cost you more than the ones for the HD24, but the SDR costs $700 less right now. That's really the only thing the HD24 has over the SDR.
Desirability:
Um, you're either into recording gear or you aren't.
Sound:
For $1300, it sounds great. The converters are not as good as those on the Mackie HDR/MDR lines, but they're very much on par with those on the Alesis HD24. Out of the box, the SDR is capable of 12+ tracks at 24 bit/96 kHz, which is pretty good. I haven't yet tested it at 24/96 with 24 full tracks, but haven't had any problems with 15 so far.
Support:
Mackie is really great to deal with. One of the best things is that they have a really well-informed forum on their website. Not only are representatives from Mackie fairly active there, but there are quite a few knowledgeable pros on there who drop in to give advice. I can't comment on any repair situations, since I haven't had to have any done.
Overall:
At this price level, it's the thing to get. If I were to move up, it would be to a Mackie HDR or Radar system. I'd buy this one again if this one were stolen or somehow lost. I don't see myself outgrowing the SDR unless I end up getting a lot of cash coming in.
Did you find this review helpful?
Thanks for your opinion!