Feature:
Again, the plug-ins sound really great to me, rich warm and very flexible while still being quite easy for the recording student to sound very good.
Quality:
Here I give a 3 because I cannot possible get Logic to run on either of my systems in OS9. I've tried it on my G3/900/640mb ibook that has NEVER frozen before and even when using a 7200rpm drive for audio, Logic freezes OS9 every time. I tried my G4/800/1GB exactly the same. This is for me dissappointing as I use a PODxt to record, (no osx drivers.) On the up side, Logic works Perfectly! in OSX, even on my ibook, and is fantastic for midi sequencing and sync with no hardware beyond a midi interface!
Value:
I bought logic half for advanced midi sequencing, half for audio multitracking. I knew it might not run well on my g3, but I certainly expected it to run on my G4, which had been running Logic 4.7 until last week when I upgraded to 6.0. Sadly I was mistaken, and it has cost me much of my patiience and really interrupted my ability to just play music!
Desirability:
Everyone else seems to want it, Eminem, Autuchre, NIN, if I was rich too I would use it, but right now I just need something that works without buying a whole bunch of gear or a brand new expensive (g5) computer just to run it! Also, I am saddened that it is only Apple now, and cannot but think this may just further polarize the already unfortunately great divide between the machines. Personally I like and use both and wish there was more overlap, ala Reason, Reaktor, ect.
Sound:
The sound is really fantastic, if it were stable on my computer I would love it forever!
Support:
I don't plan to waste much more time trying so solve LA/OS9's issues, I'll probably either keep it for midi+B3 ect. plugins/return it/sell it and go for Cubase SX/Acid/Reason for my audio needs on PC, which would be a pity as I love LA's filters and plugins.
Overall:
I love the midi editing, the plugins, the clean sleek look, but have spent way too many hours just trying to get the basics to work in OS9. I would probably be much happier if I had a G5 to run it on as Jobs advertized.
Did you find this review helpful?
Thanks for your opinion!